[AI] Asmarino Independent

  • Create an account
    *
    *
    *
    *
    *
    Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required.
You are here: Home News Eritrea's president declares me 'insane'

Eritrea's president declares me 'insane'

Write e-mail Print
Photo by EPA

About Jane Dutton

Jane Dutton's picture
Jane Dutton is a Senior News Presenter with extensive experience of international news, both in-studio and on location.

Jane Dutton visits an art deco city, watches women and children being beaten and is told she is "insane"  by the leader she has come to interview. 

We hadn't even arrived in Eritrea when I started to get a sense of the man I had been sent to interview.

Our flight from Dubai airport was delayed.
 
Nobody told us for how long or why. Four hours later, when the plane finally arrived, we found out the president had decided to borrow it for the morning, on a whim.
 
We were on our way to one of Africa's most secretive regimes.
 
Granted a rare interview with the Eritrean president, Isaias Afewerki, a man constantly ranked in the top 10 of the world's worst dictators and accused of helping turn the Horn of Africa into one of the most volatile regions on the planet.
 
Our plane - Eritrea's only carrier - was one of the few international flights that still fly into the country: a desolate place blighted by years of war with Ethiopia and Yemen, and increasing political isolation.
 
At the airport we were met by unfamiliar silence - no network connections, no SIM cards, no blackberry! And Rafael, our minder.
 
Rafael is a man of contradictions: even his backcomb appears to grow forward.
 
"Let me tell you the truth," he would say every couple of hours, immediately followed by anything but.
 
He also ominously warned that he could keep a watch on our every movement if he chose to do so, at our hotel, on the job.
 
Our interview was scheduled for Saturday and we were told it would take two hours to get to the city of Massawa, the president's new bunker retreat on the coast.
 
He is reported to spend more time there after an attempted assassination last year.
 
The roads are manned by checkpoints. The population's every move seems to be watched and noted in this country.
 
And it probably is. Eritreans need a visa to leave and there is very little chance of them ever getting one.
 
But that hasn't stopped tens of thousands escaping every year.
 
The UN estimates that 63,000 sought asylum abroad in 2009. Around 1,800 brave the shoot-to-kill police orders to cross over into Sudan every month.
 
The majority say they are fleeing the permanent military service and repressive nature of the regime.
 
After several shouting bouts with Rafael, we finally get to Massawa, an exotic port city built by the Turks in the 14th century - a fascinating place with narrow alleyways and looming mosques. It is supposed to be the hottest place on earth. And I would concur.
 
I noticed then it wasn't just the capital that was surprisingly clean - everywhere we went in Eritrea was immaculate.

The streets are shiny bright, the hotels are spick and span, even the food is safe.
 
Our interview was delayed by a day and instead we were corralled into watching Massawa's 20-year celebrations of liberation from Ethiopia.
 
We decided to shoot a promo for our interview while we were there. People were out in that sweltering weather to see their long-time leader, carefully controlled by police.
 
What amazed us was that the police had no qualms about beating women and children with sticks a few feet away from where we were shooting. A truly shocking scene. And our cameras were still rolling.
 
The next day we were all set up and ready at our interview location in time for the planned dawn o'clock interview. We guessed the president would keep us waiting, and he did.
 
Six hours later he arrived. We were all drenched with sweat and jangled with angst by the time he sat down.
 
Was he going to throw us out of the country for asking the questions we wanted asked?
 
Why is he helping Iran supply weapons to Hamas in Gaza and the Houthi fighters in Yemen?
 
Why does he order the police to shoot-to-kill anyone escaping from the country?
 
Why is there no free press or free speech? Why were all of his political opponents whisked away never to be seen again?
 
How come he refuses to let aid agencies feed the two-thirds of his country who are starving?
 
This was a man who came in on a promise of liberating his people 20 years ago.
 
Every question I asked was met with a blank stare, a flat denial, cold laughter and finally allegations that we were making it all up. And he told me personally I am simply insane.
 
Back in the car and back on the winding roads, climbing thousands of feet to the cooler capital of Asmara.
 
You can smell coffee percolating through the streets: thick, lovely and freshly brewed - the legacy of Italy's colonial rule under Benito Mussolini's fascist regime.
 
All the buildings boast a beautiful jaded art deco influence, and the streets are full of old men cycling with their hats doffed to one side alongside colourful Fiats from the 1960s.
 
We ended the day with a piece to camera from the tank graveyard on the outskirts of the city. Thousands of armoured vehicles dismantled and stacked heading for the trash heap.
 
They were used in the 30-year battle against Ethiopia. And although that was two decades ago, Eritrea remains on a permanent war footing.
 
The majority of the population is conscripted – whether it be in the army, in the hotel bar, as a street cleaner or our ever present minder Rafael.
 
They remain braced for an Ethiopian attack that may never come.

 

Comments  

 
+3 #72 true 2010-03-02 18:53
jane dutton you did the best thing to show the real figure of the president, the world itself didn't understand who is the president. he is crazy and needs medical check up to prove his health condition wheather he is mud or not. any how you did your mission in the right way as a journalist.
 
 
+4 #71 agkal 2010-02-27 14:46
Well done Jane, you have done great job, to nullify all his puffiness. This man's dictatorship must end as soon as possible. He has became so arrogant to disturb the peace of the region and the stability of the poor citizens of Eritrea who more than ever looking help from the world super powers.
Please take an action to rescue the people who are suffering in side and in different refugee camps around the country mostly Sudan, Ethiopia and Uganda.
 
 
+1 #70 Peace TO eri 2010-02-27 02:52
Real Eritrea, get a life and know about the world you are living in! it is not about Agame or the people that you are claiming to wipe out out of the face of the earth. It is about your brothers and sisters that are suffering in Eritrea that Miss Jane is talking about. So if you are as real as you claim to be, be real and deny that HE IS A BIG FAT LIAR!
 
 
+1 #69 taazabi 2010-02-25 18:19
Is everybody execusing on the dictators interview
we all know that he was crazy long time ago
but why are people going crazy beating him to second place
I guess if they had the chance to be president there will be time we will miss issayas.
 
 
+2 #68 big mike 2010-02-25 12:44
After I watched that interview I am ashamed to call that guy my president. To make the matter worse Mr. President was calling Jane Dutton insane he is the one who is insane, for those who lives abroad and screaming to get attention from him go back there be with him. Because you are not true Eritreans.
 
 
+2 #67 mike Asmerom 2010-02-25 02:37
Quoting Insane:
[quote name="Insane"]Thank you Jane for this interview. For those who know Isaias this is no surprise. However, your interview points out to the fact that this man is the only one who is insane and a liar. He was even not able to argument his lies instead he shows to the world what an arrogant president is. Eritrea and the people of Eritrea deserve much better than this man and this life. I hope that one day we will be pride of our country by telling to children that Isaias was an old bad dream

well said
 
 
+2 #66 ben20101972 2010-02-24 23:56
Jane Dutton you ask him in his face the most important thing
he reply all lies, but my ancestor's they used to say "you can protect a thief, but you can,t protect a liar, a liar is always a liar". So this dictatorship he can fool the people who follow him, but he can't fool the people of Eritrea. Once again, i always say those people in western countries they feel freedom, and they went to demonstrate against UN, but they fooled themselves , soon the truth of this evil, it will come out.

Long live the brave Eritrean's who sacrafice their lives.
 
 
+3 #65 Wedi Habte 2010-02-24 20:46
By the time I listened to the interview ,two things came up to my mind immediately.Either the president was intoxicated or suffering from schiziophrenic paranoia in which he was totally denying reality ,following illogical patterns accompanied with intellectual disturbances.
The first time I heard about the interview ; I didn't expect much from him except on the contrary.As an Eritrean I was extremeley emrarassed to have such an ill president.

Thanks Dutton.
 
 
+2 #64 Insane 2010-02-24 13:19
[quote name="Insane"]Thank you Jane for this interview. For those who know Isaias this is no surprise. However, your interview points out to the fact that this man is the only one who is insane and a liar. He was even not able to argument his lies instead he shows to the world what an arrogant president is. Eritrea and the people of Eritrea deserve much better than this man and this life. I hope that one day we will be pride of our country by telling to children that Isaias was an old bad dream
 
 
+6 #63 dan 2010-02-24 03:49
The dictator has gone from bad to worse.
He is loosing it.
 
 
+8 #62 Zblo Aloni 2010-02-23 23:26
I watched the interview again and thought of Mr Afework as a narcissist who has a grandiose sense of self-importance. He exaggerates his achievements in order to be recognized as superior, but in reality his accomplishments are mediocre, if there ever is one. To use his word “fantasy”, he fantasizes attaining unlimited success or power. He believes he is special and deserves excessive admiration. He lacks empathy and exploits blind-followers in the Diaspora to achieve his own ends. He is controlling because he only matters.
 
 
+9 #61 Senkim 2010-02-23 22:08
Thank you Ms. Dutton for asking the dictator some of the question that many Eritrean journalists were/are craving to ask. But then again for daring to ask questions far less tricky, they founded themselves behind bars. Reste assured though, Eritrea has much lore to offer that the shameless and pathetic dictator
 
 
+13 #60 He s not my presiden 2010-02-23 20:30
Love it! excellent analogy!

Quoting Yes to Sanctions:
Two girls were walking on the street when a drunken driver trampled on them and killed one of the girls. The survived girl screamed on the driver "What the hell have you done ? "you killed my friend"....the drunken driver jumped on her and said "Since she is not speaking then why are screaming on her behalf"

Like the drunken driver, the dictator told Jane Dutton why are speaking on the behalf of those whom I Isias killed, detained, tortured, marginalized, humilnated etc,,,let them speak by themselves.
 
 
+2 #59 bebe 2010-02-23 20:10
COMICAL ALI of East africa!!!
 
 
-10 #58 wedi asmara 2010-02-23 18:57
good interview, bad interview..........whats the big deal ..i have seen 1000s of politicians being grilled in the past.............whats new???????

did you expect him to give a slick and well oiled interview like the ones we are fed in the west by well trained ..media savvy mostly career and corrupt politicians.........well isayas isnt one of those........you should know that by now

or do you have such a high expectation of ISAYAs,

I wonder why...is it because you know him to be right?????
 
 
+6 #57 Yes to Sanctions 2010-02-23 17:24
Two girls were walking on the street when a drunken driver trampled on them and killed one of the girls. The survived girl screamed on the driver "What the hell have you done ? "you killed my friend"....the drunken driver jumped on her and said "Since she is not speaking then why are screaming on her behalf"

Like the drunken driver, the dictator told Jane Dutton why are speaking on the behalf of those whom I Isias killed, detained, tortured, marginalized, humilnated etc,,,let them speak by themselves.
 
 
+6 #56 FREEDOM 2010-02-23 17:22
for those who demonstrated on 22 of feb,2010 to support the dictator are the once who came living in diaspora claiming they were imprisoned or afraid from the insane dictator if their refugee claim was to be opened and checked. i say to them please leave us alone go back home if the dictator is what you are supporting but remember when we got our independence many eritrean living abroad tried to go back home to do bussines or live what was the answer you got many eritrean returned back to where they were living .I would like to ask one simple question if eritrea is #1 if the dictator allowed you to live how come you still living in foreign country and shouting from far away and how come the people in eritrea not able to demonstrate about the sanction you figuare it out.the sanction was and pointed at the insane dictator for his miss guided policies, diplomacy and doing bussines in neigbouring countries for us dollar currency that he need to stay in power believe me he doesn't care about somalian people he cares about getting dollar. to cover up the lies so he sent you or ordered you to show he got plenty supporters and you guys did what he wanted to prolong his power for long time by showing your pictures and signutures to the world and particularly to eritrean people in eritrea. "gin petri haqi tiqetin ember aytsberin" the interview of the dictator with the brave jane dutton was one evidence that the dictator can say and do what ever he want did you see him taking deep breath in the interview ahahahahahha Jane wasn't asking him the the questions already approved by him he was schocked never any one dared to ask him same questions as the brave Jane dutton did and he behaved as he was sinking in a deep water.what was he thinking to have this kind of interviews and allow Jane to air the interview wondering if he got plenty of dollars from al-jaazira for his account and didn't care what the interview look like when he was acting like a kid arguing with his mom for snack eventhough she was telling him you are grounded and he said to her you are insane. and his supporters now saying please don't do any interview ever.cuz he can't cover his lies.
 
 
+7 #55 true or false 2010-02-23 17:06
all the question asked for the gone mad president was true or false ,so the president replayed all false so result ,mr president u got FFFFFFFFF IN ALL ,THE ANSWER WAS TRUE realy its hard luck try again .
 
 
+5 #54 Helen2 2010-02-23 17:02
The journalist Wrote
"Our interview was delayed by a day and instead we were corralled into watching Massawa's 20-year celebrations of liberation from Ethiopia."

During the interview isias keep asking "did you enjoy the show"?

I believe Isias plan was to show the journalist the 20 year celebration before the interview, he probably thought she will be impressed by watching the flashy dancing & decoration. LOL
 
 
+4 #53 Jonas 2010-02-23 16:15
Eritrea is the most comfortable country in the world. Eritrean Government is the most farsighted and democratic in the continent. Isayas Afeworky is the most well balanced,civil and charismatic leader in the whole world.
SO WHY YOU PFDJ SUPPORTERS DO NOT RETURN BACK IN THIS EXTRAORdINARY COUNTRY TO LIVE PERMANENTLY INSTEAD OF ARGUING FROM COMFORTABLE WESTERN DEMOCRACIES???

YOU GUYS ARE SO RIDICULOUS!!!

Thanks aljazeera for keepin spotlights pointed on our forgotten country!!!
 

Add comment

Security code
Refresh

Asmarino

ኣዝማሪኖ (ትግሪኛ)

ICER Alert on Afar

ICER Alert on Afar

There is human catastrophe unfolding in Yemen  at this very minute. Two hundred and forty four Eritreans ninety five percent of whom are Afar citizens of Eritrea are in prison some for almost one year. Their crime is simply for entering Yemen without document. Their claim for political asylum until situation at home is improved was completely ignored by the Yemeni authorities and the UNHCR is on the sideline simply watching helpless.

As it is true with most Eritreans, this particular ethnic group is driven out of their traditional areas, prevented from leading their subsistence existence which is fishing on the Red Sea and forcibly conscripted in the open ended military National Service which has become scourge ....

Read more...

Desperate Situation of Eritrean Afar Refugees in Yemeni City of Al-Hudeyda

Desperate Situation of Eritrean Afar Refugees in Yemeni City of Al-Hudeyda

Regrettably, the 300 Afar refugees are languishing in Al-Hudeyda prison where their lives are trapped in a serious threat. Apart from consistent warnings of forcible return to Eritrea, they are facing communicable diseases caused by contaminated food and water. Amongst them are around 50 Afar refugees are in a grave danger of losing their lives to this disease outbreak.

Unfortunately, the ongoing political uncertainty in Yemen exasperated the situation of Red Sea Afar refugees. Going on almost a year in captivity, they haven’t had any access to UNHCR and Human rights organizations, representatives of Yemeni government or any access to medications and basic needs, which is guaranteed to them under UN Geneva convention on rights of refugees.

Read more...

Yosief Ghebrehiwet on Smerrr Paltalk on Saturday, May 12

Yosief Ghebrehiwet on Smerrr Paltalk on Saturday, May 12

On Saturday, May 12, at 12:00 PM (Los Angeles Time) or 21:00 (Berlin Time) Yosief Ghebrehiwet will give a presentation at Smerr Paltalk. The topic is "The Fallacies of the Democracy Project and Nationhood in the Eritrean Context" In this presentation, the following points will be discussed:

  1. What is wrong with the Democracy Project as practiced by the Opposition? On this part, more than a dozen fallacies will be discussed.
  2. After discussing the notion of "nationhood" in the Eritrean context, this question will be addressed: What is being done to hold Eritrea together as a nation?
  3. After looking at the rationale of the past (the Eritrean revolution) and the present (the opposition) movements regarding (1) and (2), we will look at this question: Given the above fallacies and failings, how do we anchor the Eritrean nation in the future?

 

Read more...

ICER APPEAL: Save Eritrean Refugees from Human Smugglers

ICER APPEAL: Save Eritrean Refugees from Human Smugglers

The International Commission on Eritrean Refugees (ICER) would like to appeal to all the political groups in particular to those whose operational base is Ethiopia to give focus on the issues affecting refugees in particular to the shady operation going on in the refugee camps. Frankly, since their base of operation is located stone throw away from Eritrea where the bulk of the refugees originate from we believe they are better placed than most of us to influence events, at least in as far as regulating the flow of persons from the refugee camps in Ethiopia and the Sudan. ...

This being the case, therefore, why is it so difficult for the political parties and in particular those operating from Ethiopia where part of the illegal activities is occurring cannot act in earnest to stop it?  Is it because  they are too preoccupied dealing with the more burning issues, for example, the overthrow of the unrepresentative regime and replacing it with democratic one? ...

Read more...

Support AI

Gebre's Story - an Eritrean Refugee's African Odyssey

Gebre's Story - an Eritrean Refugee's African Odyssey

Mai-Aini Refugee Camp, Ethiopia — They crossed the border at midnight, grief-stricken at the death of their daughter the previous day. Gebre's two-year-old girl Arsama perished from the flu. The night after they buried her, Gebre, 28, and his wife Teka, 25, decided to make their way to Ethiopia.

Arsama's death was just one reason for their escape. Gebre was exasperated with seven years in the military - part of Eritrea's obligatory decades-long national service - with not even enough money to pay for food for his family. There seemed no end to the misery, Gebre recalled, here in Ethiopia.

Read more...

Eritrea Ranked as Most-Censored Country by Journalism Group

Eritrea Ranked as Most-Censored Country by Journalism Group

Eritrea is the world’s most-censored nation, ahead of countries including North Korea and Syria, the Committee to Protect Journalists said.

The three countries are joined in the top 10 by Iran and Equatorial Guinea, the New York-based organization said in a report on its website today. Reporters in Eritrea, a nation in the Horn of Africa which won independence from Ethiopia in 1993, are conscripted into their work and handed instructions on how to cover events, the group said. The last accredited foreign correspondent was expelled in 2007, it said.

“No foreign reporters are granted access to Eritrea and all domestic media are controlled by the government,” the committee said. “Ministry of Information officials direct every detail of coverage.”

Read more...

Eritrea, the most repressive nation on Earth

Eritrea, the most repressive nation on Earth

It might seem a daunting challenge to determine which of the world's repressive nations offers the least-free news media. We have so many to choose from - Iran, North Korea, Belarus ...

But you might be surprised by the unanimity among organizations that study such things, like Reporters Without Borders, a French group. The consensus choice is Eritrea, a tiny nation most people cannot even pinpoint on a map.

Eritrea, a desperately poor desert state about the size of Pennsylvania, lives in an ugly neighborhood on the Horn of Africa, between Sudan, Ethiopia and Somalia. But as tyrannical as the neighbors might be, Eritrea is in a league of its own. Conditions there are so bad that an estimated 25 percent of the population has fled over the past 20 years, even though the government classifies emigrants as "traitors," and border guards are ordered to shoot them on sight.

Read more...

ICER Action Alert: 600 Eritreans held hostages near Shegerab refugee camps

ICER Action Alert: 600 Eritreans held hostages near Shegerab refugee camps

*Reliable source informed ICER that over 600 Eritrean, children, men and women are kept in a ‘slave holding lots’ few kilometers west of Shegerab refugee camps. The story told by an Eritrean who is tirelessly fighting to stop the human trafficking by alerting new arrivals of the dangerous situation awaiting them if they are not careful and also by informing Sudanese authorities of the illegal activities  going under their nose. His information sources are the escapee and animal herders around the holding areas where he has good rapport.  It is known that the victims are held in about 12  homes, under shade of trees and in mountain caves guarded by Sudanese, Hadendwa and Beni Amer guards. The past two weeks human smuggling have become so brazen that it is done in daytime, at coffee shops and public places with no one to stop it. There are two reasons for that according to our source.

Read more...

Eritrea says its president is "fit as a fiddle"

Eritrea says its president is

ADDIS ABABA (Reuters) - Eritrea has sought to quash speculation about President Isaias Afewerki's health, saying he was "fit as a fiddle" and lambasting the United States for spreading "lies" over his condition.

Rumors have been rife in the past few years that Isaias, 66 and in power since 1993 after leading his country to independence from Ethiopia, was in poor health and required regular trips abroad for treatment.

Speculation about his health has stirred up debate over who might eventually replace the reclusive leader. Isaias has no obvious successor but the opposition says he might be grooming his son, Abraham, for the top job.

Read more...

South Sudan: Rebels Armed By Sudan, Eritrea - Small Arms Survey

South Sudan: Rebels Armed By Sudan, Eritrea - Small Arms Survey

Juba — Rebels fighting the South Sudan government are receiving weapons and ammunition from Sudan and Eritrea, says a report by Small Arms Survey; an independent research project in Geneva. ...

"In addition to Khartoum, Asmara [Eritrea] is emerging as a likely source [...] for weapons supplied to Southern rebels," the report claims.

Ammunition confiscated by the SPLA from the late George Athor's SSDM forces in Jonglei were identical to rounds were also found with Ogaden National Liberation Front (ONLF) reportedly supplied by Eritrea.

Read more...

Amid a trail of corpses, little doubt that Sudan, South Sudan are now at war

Amid a trail of corpses, little doubt that Sudan, South Sudan are now at war

HEGLIG, Disputed Sudan -- Nine months after Sudan split into two nations in search of a peace brokered by the United States, it is now clear that the two sides are at war.

Diplomats discussing the armed conflict talk of skirmishes and dustups, but a visit to this border region shows that what is taking place here is no accidental exchange of fire by troops confused about where the border lies. Instead, what’s happening is a headlong mobilization involving not just thousands of Sudan’s and South Sudan’s best forces and heaviest equipment, but heavily armed rebels from the distant Darfur region fighting alongside the South Sudanese troops.

Read more...

Detained Eritrean journalist admitted to hospital in serious condition

Detained Eritrean journalist admitted to hospital in serious condition

Reporters Without Borders has learned that the journalist Yirgalem Fisseha Mebrahtu, in custody since her arrest in February 2009, was admitted to hospital in the Eritrean capital Asmara earlier this year. The organization is extremely worried about her state of health and concerned about the conditions under which she is being held. ...

“The government of President Issaias Afewerki has already permitted the death in detention of at least four journalists. It issues no information on several others and it is not known whether they are still alive.  Today, it is the life of Yirgalem Fisseha Mebrahtu that it is playing with.” ...

According to information reaching Reporters Without Borders, Mebrahtu is in serious condition in Asmara’s Halibet hospital.

Read more...

Migrants left to die after catalogue of failures, says report into boat tragedy

Migrants left to die after catalogue of failures, says report into boat tragedy

Council of Europe investigator says deaths of migrants adrift in Mediterranean exposes double standards in valuing human life. ...

Errors by military and commercial vessels sailing nearby, plus ambiguity in the coastguards' distress calls and confusion about which authorities were responsible for mounting a rescue, were compounded by a long-term lack of planning by the UN, Nato and European nations over the inevitable increase in refugees fleeing north Africa during the international intervention in Libya.

Read more...

Eritrean leader says U.S. behind Ethiopia raids

Eritrean leader says U.S. behind Ethiopia raids

"We have seen several attacks, not just one. We prefer not to talk about it and don't intend to be involved in provocations," Isaias told Eritrean state TV in an interview late on Sunday that was later broadcast on the Internet.

"The military incursions were plotted by Washington with the aim of diverting attention from implementing the boundary commission's decision," he said.

Read more...
More:


Buying Time Eyewitness Account Blood Money News Analysis Editorial Writers' Corner News Articles Press Releases Latest